Looking to cut out unhealthy foods like trans fat, preservatives, and high fructose corn syrup, but don’t want to give up your favorite foods? I’ve been using these simple food substitutions in my recipes for years, and continue to evolve into healthier eating habits. Don’t feel like you need to make all these changes at once. Every step towards healthier eating will benefit your body.
PANTRY ITEMS:
Using this: | Try using this: |
---|---|
Breakfast cereal | Cooked oatmeal, steel cut oats or cooked millet |
Bread | B Free GF Bread or Schar Artisan Baker GF breads (Both are egg-free) |
Bread crumbs | Ground flax seeds or baked, ground garbanzo beans |
Chocolate chip | Lily’s chocolate stevia sweetened baking chips |
Cocoa powder | Raw cacao powder |
Coffee | Dandy Blend, Instant Herbal Beverage with Dandelion |
Coffee creamer | Aroy-D coconut milk in a box and pure maple syrup |
Corn chips | Trader Joe’s Grainless Cassava & Coconut Chips or Siete Grain Free Tortilla Chips |
Cornstarch | Arrowroot powder |
Flour | Trader Joe’s GF All Purpose Flour, Bob’s Red Mill GF 1 to 1 Flour, or Namaste from Costco |
Ketchup | Trader Joe’s brand, Annie’s Organic, look for one without HFCS |
Pasta | Zucchini zoodles, spaghetti squash, lentil or garbanzo bean pasta, most GF pasta are ok |
Soy Sauce | Coconut aminos |
Sugar | Coconut sugar, date sugar, raw honey or maple syrup |
Vinegar | Fresh lemon juice |

REFRIGERATOR ITEMS:
Using this: | Try using this: |
---|---|
Bacon | Applegate Organics Uncured Turkey Bacon or Trader Joe’s brand |
Butter | Coconut oil (use refined oil for no coconut flavor) |
Cheese | Miyoko’s brand cheeses |
Deli meat | Applegate Farms Organic |
Eggs | Baking: 1 Tbsp. flaxseed plus 3 Tbsp. water, let thicken for 5-10 minutes |
Ground meat | 100% grass fed beef, or organic ground turkey |
Mayonnaise | Follow Your Heart Avocado oil Vegenaise or Soy-Free Vegenaise |
Milk | Almond milk or coconut milk |
Tuna | wild-caught salmon, canned (tuna has high mercury levels) |
Whipped cream | Full-fat coconut milk Native Forest Organic Coconut Milk, Aroy-D, Nature’s Charm, 365 Whole Foods Organic Coconut Milk all work well. (Don’t use Trader Joe’s brand; it doesn’t whip.) |

My Favorite Places to Shop:
- Trader Joe’s, for most of my groceries
- Local market in summer & fall for produce
- Local Health food stores:
- Marlene’s Deli, Federal Way, WA
- PCC Natural Markets, greater Seattle area
- Costco, lots of organic
- Fred Meyer/ Kroger, un-remodeled stores “natural” section
- Whole Foods
Test out a few of these substitutions and see which ones are your favorite. A few simple changes can add up to big results!
For more helpful tips you might enjoy How To Keep Your Groceries From Spoiling Before You Can Eat Them.
One thought on “A Guide to Ingredient Substitutions for Healthier Eating”